Home Programs Advocacy About Us Awards & Events News Publications


Judicial Selection

Judicial selection is the cornerstone of Modern Courts' mission.
Indeed, it was the issue upon which the organization was founded in 1955. Among the various methods used around the country to select judges, Modern Courts endorses the system known as a "commission based appointive system" or "merit selection," and opposes open primaries. 

This page explains each judicial selection method, how each has been adapted in New York, and why Modern Courts endorses merit selection. It also outlines Modern Courts' recent policy statements.

About Judicial Selection:
Methods of Judicial Selection
Judicial Selection Charts
Historical Background of Merit Selection
Judicial Selection in the Courts of New York
Why Merit Selection?

On This Topic

2006 Policy Statement on Judicial Selection

2003 Policy Statement on Judicial Selection

Other Resources
Symposium on Rethinking Judicial Selection: A Critical Appraisal of Appointive Selection for State Court Judges
Co-Sponsored by the Fund for Modern Courts
Fordham Law School, Urban Law Journal, January 2007
New York State Office of Court Administration: The Commission to Promote Public Confidence in Judicial Elections (Feerick Commission) Final Report
Brennan Center for Justice at NYU School of Law: Fair Courts
Justice at Stake
The American Judicature Society
NYS Office of Court Administration

Testimony
January 8, 2007
Victor A. Kovner
Chair, Committee for Modern Courts
Public Hearings on the Selection of New York State Supreme Court Justices held before the New York State Senate Standing Committee on the Judiciary

November 15, 2006
Victor A. Kovner
Chair, Committee for Modern Courts
Public Hearings on the Selection of New York State Supreme Court Justices held before the New York State Assembly Standing Committee on the Judiciary


Memos
(July 2007)
Fund for Modern Courts Amicus Brief in Lopez Torres

Questions about Advocacy?
Send us an email at
advocacy@moderncourts.org

 

Home Site Map Contact Us
© 2003 The Fund for Modern Courts
351 West 54th Street New York, N.Y. 10019
Tel.: 212.541.6741
Fax: 212.541.7301
justice@moderncourts.org